To cross-list an eBay listing onto Etsy, simply copy the images, description, and item details (specifics) from the existing eBay listing into a new Etsy listing. You will need to revise the listing title and tags to reflect how users search for products on Etsy. Additionally, you must complete Etsy's "About" questions regarding the creator of the item and when it was created. Before attempting to cross-list an item, make sure that your item meets the eligibility requirements for listing on Etsy. Only vintage items that are at least 20 years old, handmade items, and crafting materials may be listed on Etsy. Therefore, a two-year-old mall brand jacket would not meet these criteria.
What you need before you open the Etsy form
A completed eBay listing contains almost everything Etsy requires to list an item; however, it is in a different format than Etsy prefers. An eBay listing title has a character limit of 80 characters, and is formatted specifically for eBay's keyword searches. The item specifics have been completed. Photos have been added to the listing, and measurements can be found within the item description. Etsy will use most of these items, but will add additional questions that were not asked by eBay. Etsy would like to know who created the item, if the item is complete (finished product), or if it is a supply. Additionally, Etsy would like to know approximately when the item was produced. These answers will determine if the item can be listed on Etsy, therefore you should consider them as the first step in listing your item on Etsy rather than a form to fill out.
Have these ready before you start, one tab or folder per item:
- The original photograph files. While it is possible to download photos from eBay, the actual files that you have stored on either your mobile device or personal computer are more clear and do not contain any cropped images.
- I have copied the eBay item description and item specifications into a plain text document, which allows you to modify the content of these areas without the formatting used by eBay.
- Evidence that shows how old a piece is (e.g. union tags, RN numbers, care label styles, date codes) and a note of the decade you believe the piece was made in.
- Etsy store has been created, payment information has been entered and you have at least one shipping profile. Most sellers will spend about 20 minutes creating their shipping profiles while they are in the process of creating a product listing.
- Etsy has a listing charge of $0.20 per item that will be active on their site for up to four months, an Etsy transaction fee of 6.5%, and in the United States, Etsy charges a payment processing fee of approximately 3% and $0.25, therefore determine your minimum acceptable price prior to entering a figure.
If you have less than 200 items in stock, you can easily do this manually for your best-selling vintage products. Set aside 10-15 minutes for each product when you are new to the process, and approximately 7 minutes when you get comfortable with it. Begin with products that are obviously older, and that are well photographed. These will be the ones that will make sense to spend $0.20 and the time on.
Steps to move one eBay listing onto Etsy
Begin working on each listing individually in this sequence, as the eligibility response will appear initially in Etsy's form, and all other responses are based on that.
- In two separate tabs, open the eBay listing and the Etsy Shop Manager. Once you have opened these two tabs, navigate to Listings, and click on "Add a listing".
- Answer "Who made it?" If you or someone in your shop made it, select "I did." If you bought it and are now reselling it as a vintage item, select "Another company or person."
- Select from either a final item that will be used for apparel, household items and/or personal accessories; or a component/tool that can be used to produce items with fabrics, beads and/or patterns.
- Identify the time frame in which the product was produced based on the labeling and/or construction of the product. Select a decade span that you feel confident about supporting through either labeling or construction. To classify an item as "vintage," it must be 20 years or older.
- Select the category. Etsy's category structure is different than eBay's. Therefore, search for your item by its product type (e.g. Jacket and coat), rather than using eBay's category name.
- Upload your photos in the same sequence as eBay, beginning with the front image. Etsy has a lower photo limit than eBay's 24, therefore eliminate similar looking images (i.e., near duplicates) and retain labels, flaws and measurement images.
- Rewrite the title. Etsy allows you to use up to 140 characters. You should list what the item is and when it was made, then the materials used, the color of the item, and finally the size. Do not use any eBay-specific terminology (such as NWOT or EUC) as these terms are seldom used by shoppers on Etsy.
- Please provide the description so that I can assist you with editing. I will remove references to "Best Offer" and "eBay returns" from the description while preserving all other information including measurements, condition notes and flaws exactly as provided.
- Fill out the characteristics of each eBay item by moving its item specifics into the appropriate Etsy attributes, like primary color, secondary color, size and material. Only move those that are applicable on Etsy.
- The first step in creating tags is to list at least 13 possible tags. Each tag can contain up to 20 characters. When choosing your tags, it's best to use multi-word phrases (like "80's ski jacket") that shoppers are likely to type into search engines when looking for products, as opposed to single-word phrases that simply restate your product title.
- Set the price and quantity. Use quantity 1 for one-of-a-kind secondhand pieces.
- Select your shipping profile and input both the calculated packed weight and dimensions for accurate shipping quote calculations.
- To use either automatic or manual renewal. Automatic renewals will be billed for an additional $0.20 per month (charged every 4 months) until the item is sold.
- Click the Publish button, go to the active listing, and view it as if you were a potential customer; make sure that everything looks right with regard to photos, titles and pricing.
- In your inventory sheet, record the Etsy listing ID alongside the eBay item number. This will allow you to quickly identify when to close the eBay listing after selling a product through Etsy, or vice versa.
The step that most people will skip, and why the exact same jacket gets sold two times. If you have only a few cross-listed items then all you need is a simple spreadsheet with columns for SKU, eBay Item Number, and Etsy Listing ID. Each day you should check both sales feeds and when one sells you can remove the other listing immediately.
Worked example: a 1980s ski jacket from eBay to Etsy
Here's an example of what it looks like to go through each of the steps using a real item (a teal and purple nylon ski jacket) being sold on eBay for $68. The title of the eBay listing read: "Vintage 80s Ski Jacket Teal Purple Nylon Insulated Mens L Retro Color Block EUC." There are 79 characters, which is just short of the 80 character limit that eBay has. Item specifics were: Size L; Color Multicolor; Material Nylon; Decade 1980s; Style Ski Jacket.
About Section. Who Created It? A different company or individual. What Is It? A final product. When Was It Created? Somewhere in the time frame of the 1980s. The Care Label uses old washing symbols and the Zipper Pull has a maker mark which is typically found on outerwear created in the 1980s. The Color Blocking matches up to catalogs that were published in the years of 1985 through 1989. This Jacket is approximately 37 to 41 years old and therefore, exceeds the requirement of Etsy's 20-year vintage rule.
I am going to use Category: Men's Clothing -> Jackets & Coats. For my Etsy listing I have decided to take 10 of the photos from eBay (eBay had 14) which included; Front view, Back view, Both Sleeves laid flat, Label, Zipper pull, Lining, Pit to Pit Measurement, Length measurement and One small snag on the Left Cuff. The four angle shots I left out did not show anything different than what was already shown.
New title, 117 characters: 80s Ski Jacket Teal Purple Color Block Insulated Nylon Windbreaker Vintage 1980s Retro Winter Coat Men's Large. I removed "EUC" and included the item's condition in the description. Attributes: Primary Color: Blue; Secondary Color: Purple; Size: L. Tags: 80s ski jacket, vintage ski coat, color block jacket, retro windbreaker, 1980s outerwear, teal jacket, purple jacket, mens vintage coat, apres ski, insulated jacket, 80s windbreaker, ski bum gift, retro winter coat.
Price. On Etsy, the fee for a $68 listing would be $0.20 for the listing fee, $4.42 for the transaction fee, and approximately $2.29 for the processing fee. This results in a total of approximately $6.91. My listing on Etsy was at $72, resulting in a fee of approximately $7.29, so that my earnings from Etsy were similar to those received on eBay after the final value fee. Shipping Profile: I used a medium box profile, packing the item to weigh 2 pounds 4 ounces, and shipping it in a 14 x 10 x 4 inch box. Renewal: I chose to manually renew the listing because I wanted to review the listing at four months. Total time spent was 12 minutes. The Etsy listing ID was added to my sheet under the column for the eBay item number.
Checklist before and after you publish
These cross-listed items should go through each of the following checks. If one of your Etsy listings does not meet the criteria for being listed, it may be removed by Etsy, putting your store in jeopardy.
- The listing is either: vintage (20+ years old), made by yourself or your business, or a material used in making crafts.
- The when was it created response is supported by what is visible on your photos (e.g., tags, labels, construction details).
- There is no mention of a reproduction or modern item being called "vintage" anywhere in the item's listing (i.e., its title, tags and description).
- The title leads with the item and era and contains no eBay shorthand.
- All 13 tags are used, and none simply repeats a single title word.
- These fields have been completed using the same information as the eBay item specific fields for color, size, and materials.
- Every flaw described on eBay is also described and photographed on Etsy.
- The description no longer mentions eBay, Best Offer or eBay's return policy.
- The price is calculated to cover all of Etsy's fees (listings, transactions, and processing) based on the margin you desire.
- The shipping profile, packaging weight, and dimensions should be the same as the box you plan to ship with.
- Quantity is set to 1 for one-of-a-kind pieces.
- The eBay listing identification number, as well as the Etsy listing identification number, are both stored at the same time in order to allow a transaction on either platform to result in the cancellation of the other listing.
Crosslist eBay to Etsy faster with PrimeLister
I spend a lot of time on two slow aspects of my job. One is that I have to enter the same information into a second form. The second is that I need to make sure I take down the original listing as soon as something sells. It takes me 12 minutes per item to list them on Etsy. If I have 40 items of vintage clothing to sell, then that means that listing them will require a full working day. I can use a spreadsheet to prevent double selling, but only if I refer to it prior to each sale. PrimeLister saves me time with both of these issues. PrimeLister lists all of my items on multiple platforms, so Etsy is just one additional location where customers can find my products rather than requiring a separate listing process.
- Cross-list your items from your existing eBay inventory to Etsy, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, and Facebook Marketplace to reach a larger number of potential customers with every product you list.
- The inventory sync with automatic de-listing of items allows for the removal of all other copies of an item from sale after one has been sold. This prevents a customer from purchasing the same jacket more than once.
- Bulk action on numerous listings, for relocating a group of vintage items simultaneously rather than as individual forms.
- A free find-duplicates tool to catch items listed more than once.
- You can use analytics to monitor your vintage stock's sell-through rate and how long it has been listed on Etsy to determine if Etsy is actively selling your vintage items.
You will continue to answer the question, "who made it" and "when" for Etsy yourself, as these are based on your personal opinion of each product; however, after that, you no longer have to manually copy and delete items from your shop.
Questions sellers ask next
Can I cross list items that are neither vintage nor handmade? No, not on Etsy. A jacket purchased in 2019 from a chain store would not fit into any category on Etsy. Therefore, you should sell this item on eBay and other sites which allow for general resale such as Poshmark, Mercari or Depop.
Yes, you may. However, you should compare the fees for each site before doing so. Since Etsy has a transaction fee of 6.5% and a payment processing fee that is typically lower than eBay's final value fee on clothing items, many sellers will price their items at the same level on both platforms and take the extra profit from selling through Etsy. Other sellers may choose to increase their prices by $1-$2 to help offset the cost of the $0.20 renewal fees that occur every time an item sells on Etsy.
If you are uncertain about the decade, select the widest possible date range supported by your documentation, and state clearly in the listing's description how you established the date. If you cannot establish with reasonable certainty that the object is at least 20 years old, do not include it on Etsy.
