Crosslist items that sell on one marketplace, but not on others, and leave a healthy margin after fees. Once listed, score the post based on age, likes, category fit and margin. Based on the scores, copy the 20 highest scoring listings. A batch of 20 is small enough to finish in two evenings, and big enough to show you if the marketplace is worth more of your time.
Before you start: what you need on hand
The majority of sellers who start crossing list have one primary account, and a secondary account which is empty or almost empty. For example, you may have 150 active listings on Poshmark, and have just created a Mercari account. Copying your 150 listings to Mercari sounds like a good idea, but at a few minutes per item it takes 8 to 12 hours of work, and the truth is a good percentage of those items will sell on Poshmark in the next week, and some will never sell on Mercari. When you are strategic about your first batch to list on Mercari, you can maximize your effort by choosing items that will actually benefit from the added exposure.
At this volume, you're better off copying and pasting. You open the original listing, paste the title and description in the new listing, upload the photos, and set a price. People with under 200 listings don't need software to tell them which items to list first. A spreadsheet and an hour of sorting does the job.
Have these ready before you score anything:
- A spreadsheet with each listing on a separate row with columns for: item name, list date, likes, category, your cost, your current price, and a score.
- Photos stored on your computer and phone in their original format so you do not have to take additional photographs for copied versions.
- The seller fees pages for both marketplaces, are open in a tab. Things change, so don’t rely on a number you remember.
- Spend 10 minutes looking at sold listings on the second marketplace for your main categories to get a feel for what sells there.
- List of which items are bundled, on-hold, or sold to a buyer, so they are not listed.
You will also need to decide how you're going to stop items from being sold multiple times. If you have 20 crosslisted items, a manual habit works. You get a sale notification? Open the other app and delete or mark the match before you pack anything. Write that rule down, because a double sale is the real cost of crosslisting, and that risk increases with every item you add.
If your first marketplace doesn't clearly show likes or views, use other signals it provides: watchers, saves, offers received, or comments. The method I will show you uses some sort of signal that a buyer has noticed the item. It doesn't require perfect data. For this method, you will be ranking 150 items to find the best 20, not trying to predict or forecast how many items you will sell, so it is perfectly fine if your numbers are a bit off.
Steps: score, sort and build a batch of 20
The fastest way to pick a first crosslisting batch is to give each listing a 0 to 2 score on 4 factors and take the 20 highest totals. Do the scoring in one sitting to ensure you judge each item the same way. Each step below is one action and in the order you take it.
- Export or type your active listings into the spreadsheet, one per row, including list date, likes, category, costs and price.
- Remove all items bundled, on hold, reserved, damaged, and priced under your minimum worth shipping, and place them in a separate tab.
- Score age: 0 points for items listed under 30 days, 1 point for items listed 30 to 90 days ago, and 2 points for items listed more than 90 days ago. Older items have had their chance with your current buyers.
- In score keeping, 0 points means no likes. 1 point means 1-4 likes. 2 points means 5 or more likes. Likes without a purchase means people want the item, but either haven't found it at the right time/place to buy it, or feel indifferent towards it.
- Score category fit: 2 points if you found more than 2 similar items sold recently on the second marketplace, 1 point if you found 1 or 2, 0 if you found none.
- Score margin: Subtract your total cost (materials + time + tools) from the price after fees are taken by the second marketplace you sell on, and shipping. Give 2 points if the margin is more than half the price, 1 point if between a quarter and a half of the price, 0 if less than a quarter.
- Add the four scores into a total out of 8.
- After total, sort by margin score as the tiebreaker.
- Locate the top 20 rows and label Batch 1.
- Crosslist Batch 1 in that order, including the photo.
- Add the name of the second marketplace to each Batch 1 row to easily identify which items are listed in both marketplaces.
- Recheck in 14 days, note what sold, and create Batch 2 from rows 21 to 40.
Taking the 12 best candidates will keep you honest about the tiebreaker. If two items have the same margin score, the item with the better margin score will be listed first.
Age score: items less than 30 days get a score of 0. Items that old are copying for a reason. A strong case to be made for an item that’s popular may still be copied.
Worked example: a 150-item Poshmark closet going to Mercari
This is the method run on a real world closet: 150 Poshmark listings (mostly women's clothing with a few shoes and home goods) and a new Mercari account. The seller spent about 70 minutes on the spreadsheet and searched Mercari sold listings for her six main categories prior to scoring.
Removals came first. Four items were in an open bundle, two were reserved for a regular buyer, and nine were priced at $12 or less (which were deemed not worthy of being copied) leaving 135 items to score.
The scoring spreadsheet looked like this. There were 41 items listed over 90 days, 52 items listed between 30-90 days, and 42 items were listed less than 30 days. Regarding likes, there were 23 items with 5 or more likes, 61 items with 1-4 likes, and 51 items with no likes. The Mercari sold search showed recent sales of sneakers, denim and small kitchen items, a few sales of blazers and dresses, and nothing of the tops. The best margins were on denim and sneakers.
| Item | Age | Likes | Category fit | Margin | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levi's 501 jeans, listed 140 days, $38, cost $4 | 2 | 2 (9 likes) | 2 | 2 | 8 |
| Nike Air Max 90, listed 75 days, $65, cost $15 | 1 | 2 (6 likes) | 2 | 2 | 7 |
| Le Creuset mug set, listed 110 days, $42, cost $8 | 2 | 1 (3 likes) | 2 | 2 | 7 |
| Banana Republic blazer, listed 50 days, $34, cost $6 | 1 | 1 (2 likes) | 1 | 2 | 5 |
| Boutique top with tags, listed 20 days, $28, cost $14 | 0 | 1 (1 like) | 0 | 0 | 1 |
After sorting, 6 items scored 8, 11 scored 7, and 19 scored 6. Batch 1 took all 17 items scoring 7 or 8 and the three highest margin items from the 6s, for a total of 20. The batch was 7 pairs of jeans, 5 pairs of sneakers, 4 kitchen items, 2 jackets, and 2 dresses. No boutique tops made it, which coincided with her sold searches: they weren’t a good fit for Mercari at that moment, despite their quality.
Copying took her about 4 minutes per item once she got a rhythm: open Poshmark listing, copy title and description, upload photos, select Mercari category and condition, and enter price. Twenty items took about 80 minutes over the course of 2 evenings. She added a Mercari column to her spreadsheet and typed an M next to each copied line.
After 14 days she reviewed the sheet. Items had sold on Mercari and a couple had sold on Poshmark. She delisted the copies within the hour of receiving notification. The categories that sold on Mercari indicated to her where Batch 2 should lean. She rebuilt the next 20 items from rows 21 to 40, giving them a slight category fit bump. Your own results will vary; the purpose of the exercise was to show that 2 weeks of actual data beats guesswork for the next batch.
Checklist: confirm Batch 1 is done right
Once you have copied 20 items, take a few minutes to go through your list and make sure you have protected each item from selling twice. Continue this process the next time you copy 20 items. Also at the 14 day mark, make sure you have completed your 2nd cross-listing batch.
- Each row in Batch 1 has the 2nd marketplace listed.
- All copies have the same photos and descriptions of the flaws and condition as the original.
- No bundling or holding items have been included in the batch.
- The margin was calculated using the 2nd marketplace's fees, not the first.
- You have adjusted the package size and weight of each item to the 2nd marketplace to ensure you are getting the margin you want.
- You have both notifications turned on for each app and know the rule - "delist before packing".
- You have set a reminder on your calendar to review the results in 2 weeks and begin working on batch 2.
- Items that have sold have been moved to a sold tab to be used for scoring batch 2.
Fix any issues with your current listings before adding more. A minor issue like a size mismatch or missed delist will ultimately cost you more than taking the time to do it correctly.
Crosslist your best items faster with PrimeLister
The scoring method works like this: You hand score the batch, and two things get painful as the batch stack up: copying and pasting the listings and delisting the copy once it’s sold. With over 40 or 60 or 100 items in two different locations, a single missed delist would result in a double sale. PrimeLister solves both problems, so you don’t have to spend your evenings doing Score & Scan.
- Additionally, this tool allows you to cross-list items on Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, Depop, Etsy and Facebook Marketplace.
- It also syncs your inventory and sells one of each item, removing the need to manually delist an item.
- And it allows you to take bulk actions on multiple listings, so a batch of 20 can be delisted, edited or closed at the same time.
- It provides analytics on sell-through rate and average time items spend on market.
- It has a free tool to find duplicate items.
The Poshmark bot, which is also included, has a 7-day free trial with no credit card required.
